HDMI eARC vs Optical for Soundbars
Quick verdict · Wiring
Prefer HDMI eARC/ARC when your TV has the labeled port — one cable for TV apps and Atmos-capable return audio. Use optical when the TV is older or you only need stereo / basic compressed surround.
Check the TV ports before chasing badges. Ports sorted? Our soundbar top picks below all work over HDMI ARC, with optical as a backup.
Connection wizard: how should I wire my soundbar?
Tick what your TV and soundbar have. You’ll get one wiring path, the TV setting to change, its limits, and the cable you need. Based on published specs and manufacturer manuals. Nothing you pick is saved or sent anywhere.
Quick rule:
- eARC on the TV and the soundbar → one HDMI cable, eARC (lossless formats possible).
- ARC on both (or eARC on one side only) → one HDMI cable, ARC (compressed 5.1; streaming Atmos on many TVs).
- No ARC, but optical on both → one optical cable (stereo or compressed 5.1, no Atmos).
- No ARC and no optical → see TV has no ARC or optical.
Why wiring before purchase
The “best” bar is useless if your TV only has optical and you needed eARC features (TV-app Atmos, higher-bandwidth return audio).
HDMI eARC — when it wins
- TV apps sending advanced audio (Atmos / multichannel where supported)
- Single-cable return audio from TV → bar
- CEC / power sync convenience (when it works)
Optical (TOSLINK) — when it’s enough
- Stereo / basic compressed surround
- Older TVs without ARC/eARC
- Isolating a simple music path (see streamer wiring)
ARC vs eARC
Both use the same HDMI socket on the TV, labeled ARC or eARC. The difference is how much audio data the return path can carry.
| HDMI ARC | HDMI eARC | |
|---|---|---|
| Stereo PCM | Yes | Yes |
| Compressed 5.1 (Dolby Digital, DTS on many TVs) | Yes | Yes |
| Dolby Atmos in Dolby Digital Plus (the kind most streaming apps use) | Yes, on many TVs | Yes |
| Lossless Dolby TrueHD (incl. Atmos) and DTS-HD Master Audio | No | Yes |
| Uncompressed multichannel PCM (5.1 / 7.1) | No | Yes |
- What eARC adds. HDMI Licensing describes eARC as an advance over ARC that supports high-bitrate audio up to 192 kHz / 24-bit, uncompressed 5.1 and 7.1, and formats such as DTS-HD Master Audio, DTS:X, Dolby TrueHD and Dolby Atmos (HDMI.org — eARC).
- What plain ARC can still do. Samsung’s support table lists Dolby Digital Plus including compressed Dolby Atmos as supported over regular HDMI (ARC), while Dolby TrueHD (uncompressed Atmos) needs HDMI eARC (Samsung support — soundbar connection types). That’s why a streaming app can show an Atmos badge on an ARC-only setup.
- Where lossless matters. Lossless TrueHD and DTS-HD Master Audio mostly come from 4K Blu-ray players and some media players plugged into the TV. If you only stream, ARC with Dolby Digital Plus covers most of what you’ll hear.
- Both ends must match. You only get eARC when the TV port, the soundbar, and the setting are all eARC. An eARC TV with an ARC-only bar falls back to ARC; the Roku TV user guide notes the eARC port is backward compatible with ARC (Roku TV User Guide).
- CEC has to be on. ARC/eARC relies on HDMI-CEC (the “control each other” feature). Brands name it differently: Samsung calls it Anynet+, and Samsung’s support page says to turn on Anynet+ (HDMI-CEC) before setting HDMI eARC Mode to Auto (Samsung US support — eARC). LG uses SimpLink and Sony uses BRAVIA Sync. CEC is also what lets the TV remote control the bar’s volume.
- Lip-sync. If voices seem slightly early or late, look for an AV sync / audio delay setting on the soundbar or TV before blaming the cable. The fix is usually a small adjustment, not new hardware. If voices are in sync but hard to make out at low volume, see TV dialogue hard to hear at night for the dialogue and night settings on each TV brand, or TV speakers for clear dialogue if the TV’s own speakers are the problem.
- The cable. eARC doesn’t need a special “eARC cable.” HDMI Licensing says a Premium High Speed HDMI Cable with Ethernet works for eARC, and that an Ultra High Speed HDMI Cable enables all HDMI 2.1 features (HDMI.org). Plain “High Speed” (10.2Gbps) cables aren’t named by HDMI Licensing for eARC. See honest HDMI / optical cables.
TV has no ARC or optical
Older TVs, some budget sets, and many computer monitors have neither an ARC HDMI port nor an optical output. You still have options, listed from simplest to most involved:
- Headphone / 3.5 mm output. Many TVs have a headphone jack that can feed powered speakers or a soundbar’s analog (AUX) input. The Roku TV user guide says headphones or an analog soundbar can plug into the headphone jack on certain models, and that doing so turns off the TV speakers. Some models also have a separate audio line out that ignores TV volume, so you control volume on the bar instead (Roku TV User Guide). Analog carries stereo only, which is fine for dialogue.
- RCA analog out (red/white). Older TVs often have Audio Out L/R jacks. Use an RCA-to-RCA (or RCA-to-3.5 mm) cable into the bar’s AUX input. Same limits as the headphone jack: stereo, no surround formats.
- Bluetooth out. If the TV can send audio over Bluetooth, pair it with a soundbar or headphones. On Samsung TVs the path is Settings → Sound → Sound Output → Bluetooth Speaker List (Samsung support). Expect some delay on some pairings, and stereo only. If your TV has no Bluetooth, wireless TV headphones with their own dock plug into the optical or headphone output instead (not HDMI ARC).
- Use the streaming stick or box’s own audio. If most of what you watch comes from a streaming device, its audio options may be enough on their own. Apple TV 4K can pair Bluetooth headphones or speakers (Settings → Remotes and Devices → Bluetooth) (Apple TV 4K User Guide). Roku offers private listening through the Roku mobile app with headphones plugged into your phone (Roku TV User Guide).
- HDMI audio extractor, fed from the source device. An extractor sits between your source (streaming box, console, Blu-ray player) and the TV. HDMI goes in from the source and out to the TV for picture, and the extractor sends the audio to your soundbar on optical/coaxial or 3.5 mm (example HDMI audio extractor manual). It only carries sound from devices plugged into it, not the TV’s own apps or tuner. For surround formats, pick one with an optical output and a soundbar with optical in.
If your TV has optical but no ARC, you’re in better shape than this section assumes: Roku notes its soundbars can take TV audio over the TV’s optical output when there is no ARC port (Roku support).
Decision checklist
- Does the TV have eARC, ARC, or optical only?
- Do you care about Atmos / advanced audio from TV apps?
- Will a streamer share the bar? → see WiiM / streamer wiring
Need the cable?
One labeled Premium High Speed (with Ethernet) or Ultra High Speed HDMI cable and one working optical cable are enough for most apartments. More on cable myths and lengths → honest HDMI / optical cables.
Ready to pick the speaker?
- Simple, slim, dialogue-first bar on HDMI ARC → best compact soundbars for apartments
- Voices are the main problem → best TV speakers for clear dialogue
- Movies with a wireless sub over eARC → best budget Atmos soundbar with sub
- Private listening on the TV’s optical or headphone output → wireless TV headphones for night